Coffee means more than a quiet pick-me-up in Manhasset. It’s a daily ritual. Locals know where to find the smoothest dark roast and the freshest pastries to pair with their cup. Whether I’m wandering down Plandome Road or in need of a calm nook after a morning of errands, I find the variety here surprisingly rich—each spot with its own character, and each mug a little different from the last. A few personal favorites even became places for impromptu laptop sessions or catching up with friends who swear by their own secret menu hacks.
This list comes from both careful research and far too much time spent testing croissants in the interest of accuracy. If you’re looking for the perfect pour-over, a bakery with real old-school charm, or a quiet spot to people-watch, you’ll find the right café for your mood right here. Let’s explore where Manhasset’s love for coffee shines brightest.
Where to find the best coffee shops in Manhasset, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best coffee shops in Manhasset, NY:
- Starbucks
- Buttercooky Bakery
- Whole Foods Market
- Cafe Continental
- Starbucks Coffee
- For Five Coffee
- Au Bon Pain
- Peet’s Coffee & Tea
- Ralph’s Coffee
- Cafe Bene
1. Starbucks
At Starbucks on Plandome Road, you’re in for a smooth blend of consistency and innovation. The space manages to feel both familiar and comforting—think cozy corners, the reliable hum of espresso machines, and a staff that greets you like a regular even on your first visit.
What sets this location apart is the genuine sense of community. I’ve sipped lattes here while prepping for meetings or just watching neighbors swap stories over cappuccinos. The ease of plugging in a laptop, or sinking into an armchair with a paperback, makes lingering feel like a small luxury.
Order a Flat White for its bold espresso or a Nitro Cold Brew when you need a real pick-me-up. Their freshly baked croissants are worth adding, soft inside and crisp on the surface—a classic match for the rich coffee that keeps folks returning.
2. Buttercooky Bakery
Stepping into Buttercooky Bakery on Plandome Road always feels like a treat. The aroma of fresh pastries and bread pulls you right to the counter. What sets this place apart is its blend of old-world technique and elegant presentation—a rare mix on Long Island.
The staff here are warm and quick to recommend something that pairs perfectly with coffee. I’ve found myself lingering over a strong American coffee and a flakey, golden rugelach, soaking in the neighborhood buzz. There’s always something new to notice behind the glass displays.
Try their almond croissant for a perfect balance of airy and rich, or pair a petite fruit tart with espresso for a sweet, classic combo reflecting the bakery’s signature style.
3. Whole Foods Market
Whole Foods Market in Manhasset isn’t just for groceries—it’s quietly one of the best spots to grab coffee and a bite. The café area has a laid-back buzz, where shoppers slip away for a hot cup and a quick snack. There’s always natural sunlight and a steady stream of locals catching up.
Freshness is the main feature. I often stop in for a house-brewed coffee and a fruit-filled scone, both made with simple, quality ingredients. You can taste the difference, a clean flavor that reflects Whole Foods’ approach to food.
Order a café au lait with a vegan muffin if you want something light yet satisfying. The menu changes often, but you’ll always find options that feel wholesome and thoughtful.
4. Cafe Continental
Cafe Continental is one of those places where you linger a little longer just to soak in the old-world charm. The setting is refined without feeling stuffy—a balance of European bistro and friendly neighborhood café. Every visit feels like a mini escape from the bustle along Northern Boulevard.
What makes this spot memorable is the blend of continental and Italian fare with a real focus on hospitality. I’ve settled into countless mornings here with a creamy cappuccino, the foam always just right, and a seat by the window to watch the world go by.
For a taste of their signature comfort, order a classic cappuccino paired with their lightly sweetened biscotti. Both reflect the café’s knack for simple quality that doesn’t need fuss.
5. Starbucks Coffee
Starbucks Coffee at 375 Plandome Road delivers the experience regulars expect—dependable, upbeat, and always humming with life. The spot tends to buzz, especially in the mornings, making it a friendly crossroads for students, commuters, and neighbors alike.
There’s a certain comfort in knowing your favorite drink is made with care, every time. I often come here to reset with a Pike Place Roast and catch up on work, savoring the steady energy and the gentle whir of conversation around me.
For those who like a twist, try a Caramel Macchiato or the Iced Shaken Espresso. Each offers a signature blend—and pairs well with their classic banana bread for a satisfying break.
6. For Five Coffee
For Five Coffee on Plandome Road has a modern vibe that gives off pure coffeehouse energy. It’s where you find both serious coffee fans and casual sippers blending in, soaking up the comfortable atmosphere and sharp design. The baristas here have that rare knack for remembering names and favorite drinks, which adds a neighborly spark.
What truly sets For Five apart is their dedication to quality roasting. I’ve dropped in for a quick espresso, only to end up chatting about beans and brewing with staff who care about every detail.
Go for the Cortado if you want something robust and smooth; it’s their specialty for a reason. Pair it with a chocolate chip cookie—soft, rich, and fresh daily—reflecting For Five’s commitment to classic favorites with a gourmet twist.
7. Au Bon Pain
Au Bon Pain inside North Shore University Hospital pulls off a rare coffeehouse feat: comfort on demand. Even on hectic weekdays, the smell of fresh bread and coffee grounds sets a calming tone. It’s an easy spot for doctors, visitors, or locals to pause and recharge.
I’ve ducked in countless times for a mid-afternoon boost, greeted by friendly staff and a pastry case that never disappoints. The café is bright and practical, always stocked with wholesome options that take the edge off a stressful day.
Order a café latte—creamy and balanced—and a freshly baked multigrain bagel. Both are simple but satisfying, capturing the best of what Au Bon Pain consistently delivers to Manhasset’s coffee crowd.
8. Peet’s Coffee & Tea
(516) 365-2473Call
Peet’s Coffee & Tea on Northern Blvd has a way of making coffee feel like a daily event. This place draws in folks who appreciate robust, handcrafted brews and a quieter, less hurried setting. There’s always room to relax—whether you’re reading, working, or catching up with friends who prefer their caffeine a shade stronger.
I’ve started many early mornings here with a cup that’s both bold and smooth, complemented by the shop’s relaxed pace. The staff have a real passion for beans, often recommending new blends or brewing styles for curious regulars.
Order the Major Dickason’s Blend when you crave something deep and full-bodied. Pair it with a buttery scone for a satisfying, comforting start to the day. Both sum up Peet’s signature approach: quality without compromise.
9. Ralph’s Coffee
Ralph’s Coffee on Northern Blvd feels as if a little slice of New York chic landed right in Manhasset. The space pairs vintage style with a modern sense of comfort—think green tiles, marble counters, and sunlight streaming across tables filled with locals and loyal fans.
This shop has a vibe that’s unmistakably Ralph Lauren: polished yet relaxed. My visits here usually turn into much-needed pauses, with a cup of Ralph’s Roast keeping me company as I leaf through the morning paper or chat with a friend.
Order the classic drip coffee if you want something rich and straightforward. Add a mini madeleine for a subtle, sweet bite that matches the elegance and easygoing spirit of Ralph’s Coffee.
10. Cafe Bene
(516) 869-8711Call
Cafe Bene on Northern Blvd is a cozy local staple where breakfast hours stretch effortlessly into lunch. The décor keeps things bright and easy, making it a favorite for casual meet-ups and solo laptop sessions alike. There’s a steady stream of regulars here for a reason.
What I appreciate most is the range. Whether I want an early bite or an afternoon treat, the menu is filled with comforting café classics and options for those on the go. Service is prompt and friendly, often with a dash of genuine small-town warmth.
Don’t miss the house coffee, reliably smooth and never bitter. Pair it with a buttery croissant or a fresh fruit bowl—their simple quality captures what Cafe Bene is all about.
More Things to Try in Manhasset, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best coffee shops in Manhasset for studying or remote work?
Several spots cater to students and professionals. For Five Coffee offers reliable Wi-Fi and a calm setting, while Starbucks on Plandome Road provides plenty of seating and power outlets.
Are there any coffee shops in Manhasset with outdoor seating?
Buttercooky Bakery sometimes puts out tables in mild weather, and Café Rustica has cozy outdoor seating—perfect for sunny afternoons.
Which coffee shops serve vegan or dairy-free options?
Whole Foods Market and Starbucks both offer plant-based milks and vegan pastry options. Some local bakeries rotate in dairy-free treats as well.
Where can I find locally roasted coffee in Manhasset?
For Five Coffee roasts their own beans and serves a fresh variety daily. Peet’s Coffee & Tea also brings their signature, deeply roasted blends straight to Manhasset.
Is there a quiet café for morning coffee in Manhasset?
Peet’s Coffee & Tea is known for its quieter mornings and robust blends, making it a great choice for those seeking a peaceful start.
