Finding a great cup of coffee in Brookville, NY doesn’t feel like a quest; it feels more like an easy stroll through a town where everyone has strong opinions about espresso, but nobody’s in a hurry to share them. I’ve spent many mornings ducking into neighborhood coffee shops, chatting with locals about which spot roasts the smoothest beans or whose muffins are truly legendary. One debate got so spirited, I ended up sampling two almond croissants before lunch—purely in the name of research.
Brookville has coffee spots for every mood. Want a secluded nook to lose yourself in a book? It’s here. Craving a giant table for studying, or a laid-back booth for swapping stories with friends? Covered. Each shop brings its own flavor: some with a swirl of nostalgia, others with a bold shot of modern style. Every place on this list has earned its spot for a reason, and you get to decide which one makes the cut in your caffeine routine. Ready to sip your way through Brookville’s best?
Where to find the best coffee shops in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best coffee shops in Brookville, NY:
- Starbucks Coffee
- New Jericho Coffe Shop
- Cafe Dolce Vita
- Cafe 125
- Allegro Coffee Company
- Kiss the Chef Cafe
- Empire Diner
- Center Coffee Shop
- Juice Box Cafe Inc
- Taby’s Burger House
1. Starbucks Coffee
Starbucks Coffee at 720 Northern Blvd is a hub for students and locals looking for a steady dose of caffeine and community. The location, tucked inside the B Davis Schwartz Memorial Library, makes it a favorite stop for a midday pick-me-up. The library’s cheerful buzz blends perfectly with the aroma of fresh brews.
I’ve often settled into a window seat here, laptop open, watching the outside world slip by while sipping a well-crafted Pike Place. Nothing beats the classic pairing of a Cinnamon Dolce Latte with a buttery croissant when you need a gentle reset in Brookville’s busy schedule.
This Starbucks stands out for its friendly staff and impressively quick service, even during rush hours. Try the Nitro Cold Brew for a smooth boost—it’s a local favorite and just the thing after a long afternoon of lectures.
2. New Jericho Coffe Shop
(516) 433-5632Call
New Jericho Coffee Shop, hidden on the ground floor of the Jericho Quadrangle, feels like one of Brookville’s best-kept secrets. I drifted in one rainy afternoon and stayed much longer than planned, drawn in by the gentle clatter of cups and the inviting smell of fresh coffee. This place balances a warm, laid-back vibe with a knack for memorable drinks.
What sets it apart is the friendly owner who takes time to greet regulars by name, and the reliable comfort of their house blend. The coffee always tastes just-roasted—you’ll notice locals nursing tall mugs while flipping through work papers or unwinding between meetings.
Order the cappuccino with a side of their signature biscotti. Together, they’re rich, smooth, and feel like a small reward, perfect for any afternoon retreat.
3. Cafe Dolce Vita
Cafe Dolce Vita, nestled in the Birchwood Park Shopping Center, is where Brookville meets a little slice of Italy. The atmosphere is light and inviting, with soft music and the smell of ground espresso. My first visit turned into a leisurely afternoon as I got lost in a book over endless sips of rich, velvety coffee.
This cafe shines with its European flair and homemade pastries. The staff treat every guest like family, often suggesting pairings you won’t find posted on the wall. You sense a genuine warmth here—nothing rushed or routine.
Order the classic cappuccino paired with a fresh ricotta cheese danish. The cappuccino arrives with a perfect foam cap, and the danish is soft and subtly sweet. Both are standouts, reflecting the cafe’s love for authentic flavors and comfort.
4. Cafe 125
(516) 333-5840Call
Cafe 125, tucked along Jericho Turnpike, feels like the definition of a classic neighborhood hangout. The setup is simple but inviting, perfect for catching up with a friend or taking a quiet coffee break during a hectic day. My go-to move is pairing a smooth cup of their daily drip with a seat by the window—ideal for a quick reset.
The beauty of Cafe 125 is its steady reliability. You know what you’re getting: freshly brewed coffee, friendly faces, and no unnecessary fuss. It’s the kind of place where the regulars rarely need to ask for their usual orders.
The must-try here is the house blend coffee with a toasted bagel. The flavors are straightforward and comforting, showing Cafe 125’s devotion to the basics done right.
5. Allegro Coffee Company
Allegro Coffee Company on North Broadway is a treasure for anyone who appreciates a careful approach to coffee. I stopped in after hearing locals rave about their sourcing and left with a newfound respect for their craft. The aroma when you walk in hints at single-origin quality, and every detail feels thoughtfully curated.
What sets Allegro apart is their focus on ethical sourcing and flavorful roasts. The baristas are happy to share insights about any bean or blend, making every visit both educational and satisfying. There’s a genuine sense of artistry here—you can taste it in every cup.
If you’re curious, order the pour-over or the smooth vanilla latte. Both offer layers of flavor that highlight why Allegro stands out among Brookville’s caffeine crowd.
6. Kiss the Chef Cafe
(516) 307-9400Call
Kiss the Chef Cafe on Jericho Turnpike has a knack for feeling both relaxed and lively at the same time. I ended up here by accident one crisp morning, and the memory of their warm service has stuck with me. There’s an easy, communal feel—regulars chat with staff, and first-timers feel like they’ve stumbled into something special.
This spot stands out because the menu goes beyond a standard cafe. You’ll find comforting classics made with care, reflecting a homestyle flair in everything from their fresh brews to the daily baked goods. It’s the epitome of casual but never careless.
Try the robust house coffee paired with a homemade muffin. The combination is simple yet spot-on, and it speaks to Kiss the Chef’s commitment to straightforward, honest flavor.
7. Empire Diner
(516) 433-3350Call
Empire Diner on North Jerusalem Ave is the kind of place that makes you appreciate classic Americana. The chrome details, cozy booths, and bustle remind me of road trips where a cup of coffee was as important as the journey itself. My most memorable visit included a sunrise breakfast and genuinely warm conversation with the staff.
This diner stands out due to its unfussy, generous approach to both food and service. You’ll find reliable favorites here—from steaming pots of coffee to a parade of pastries that never seem to disappoint. It’s popular for early risers and late-night thinkers alike.
Order a cup of their hot coffee with a toasted English muffin. It’s the sort of comfort food that grounds you, pairing perfectly with Empire Diner’s timeless atmosphere.
8. Center Coffee Shop
Center Coffee Shop, set in the Plainview Shopping Center, is a place with genuine small-town spirit. My first stop here felt like stepping into a community meeting—neighborly faces, quick banter, and plenty of regulars who take their coffee and conversation seriously. The energy is friendly and authentic, a rare treat these days.
This spot stands out with its classic American diner feel and a menu built for comfort. Coffee arrives quickly, always piping hot, and the baked goods have a straight-from-the-oven freshness that lingers in the air. Service is always prompt and relaxed, never rushed.
Order the classic filtered coffee with a thick slice of homemade pound cake. The combination doesn’t disappoint, and it sums up the Center Coffee Shop’s straightforward, feel-good approach.
9. Juice Box Cafe Inc
(516) 334-4200Call
Juice Box Cafe Inc on Post Ave adds a splash of color and freshness to Westbury’s coffee scene. My first time there was a spontaneous detour for coffee, but I stayed for the lively atmosphere and the creative drink menu. The decor gives off a cheerful, upbeat vibe—ideal for a quick recharge or a study session that needs a lift.
What makes Juice Box Cafe stand out is its blend of classic coffee shop fare with fresh juices and healthy bites. The balance is just right for folks who want their caffeine fix alongside something nourishing. The staff is always ready with recommendations based on your mood or craving.
Don’t miss the fresh-brewed coffee paired with a seasonal fruit cup. The combo showcases Juice Box’s knack for freshness and their bright, feel-good style.
10. Taby’s Burger House
Taby’s Burger House in Oyster Bay isn’t your usual coffee haunt, but don’t overlook it when you’re after coffee with a side of serious character. The vibe is lively, with families and friends gathering over heaping plates. One rainy afternoon, I ducked in for coffee and ended up lingering as the friendly staff swapped stories and checked that every cup stayed full.
What sets Taby’s apart is how they merge a classic burger joint feel with the simple pleasures of a coffee shop. The coffee is strong and fresh, the food menu full of comfort.
Order a cup of their house coffee with a hearty side of breakfast potatoes. This combo captures Taby’s welcoming, just-one-more-cup spirit that regulars keep coming back for.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best coffee shops in Brookville, NY?
Brookville offers a mix of national names like Starbucks and unique local gems like Cafe Dolce Vita and Allegro Coffee Company. Each spot brings something different, whether it’s specialty lattes, freshly made pastries, or a quiet study nook.
Are there any coffee shops in Brookville with free Wi-Fi?
Yes, several shops—such as Starbucks and most local cafes—offer free Wi-Fi. They’re great for students, remote workers, or anyone looking to relax with a laptop.
Which coffee shop is best for studying or working?
Try Allegro Coffee Company or Center Coffee Shop for a quieter vibe, available outlets, and a laid-back atmosphere ideal for getting work done.
Do any Brookville coffee shops serve breakfast or lunch?
Many do. Cafe Dolce Vita, Empire Diner, and Kiss the Chef Cafe all serve breakfast and lunch menus alongside coffee, with fresh, simple options to keep you fueled.
Is parking available at most coffee shops in Brookville?
Most locations offer free or convenient parking, especially those in shopping centers or with their own lots.
Where can I find vegetarian or healthy options in Brookville coffee shops?
Juice Box Cafe Inc and several others provide lighter fare with fruit, salads, and vegetarian choices for a balanced bite with your brew.
Are any of these coffee shops family-friendly?
Absolutely. Spots like Madeline’s Play Cafe and Taby’s Burger House welcome families, with menu items and spaces suited for kids and adults alike.
What coffee drinks are most popular in Brookville’s cafes?
Classic options like lattes, cappuccinos, and cold brews are favorites across many spots. For something unique, try a seasonal latte or a pour-over made with local beans.
