Selden, NY may keep a low profile, but its coffee scene is surprisingly lively. Back when I wandered the back streets searching for a decent brew, I stumbled on hidden gems tucked beside delis, inside bagel shops, and even wedged next to busy laundromats. There’s something friendly in the air here, as if every barista knows your coffee order and your favorite neighborhood shortcut.
If you want real coffee, minus the fuss, this guide is for you. Whether you crave an artisan espresso or just a reliable cup of joe, you’ll find more than one shop that gets it right. From cozy morning haunts to bright, bustling cafes, each spot on this list brings something a little different to your daily grind. The hardest part? Deciding where to start.
Where to find the best coffee shops in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best coffee shops in Selden, NY:
- Coffee Booths
- Tropical Smoothie Cafe
- Starbucks
- Zara’s Deli and Bagel
- Starbucks Coffee
- Peet’s Coffee & Tea
- All Around Coffee Cup
- Caffe Amici
- IpA Of Nassau-Suffolk Counties Inc
- Proportion Cafe
1. Coffee Booths
Coffee Booths feels like that rare neighborhood find where regulars share inside jokes with the staff. The space is small, always full of chatter, and every booth seems to have a story written into its scratched tabletop. I once ducked in during a rainstorm and left with both a dry jacket and a fresh take on what coffee shop comfort means.
Their coffee tastes honest and strong, never overcomplicated. The cold brew is my top pick—smooth, with just a hint of chocolate, and poured over generous ice. Pair it with a toasted bagel or their signature egg sandwich. Even the simplest order feels personal, as if made just for you, which captures the easygoing spirit of Selden’s best spots.
2. Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Tropical Smoothie Cafe brings a splash of sunshine to Selden, even on gray Long Island mornings. The vibe is breezy and light, with staff who always seem to have a good playlist looping in the background. My last visit was the kind of pick-me-up that left me hunting for excuses to return.
It’s not just about smoothies—though their Sunrise Sunset, with its fresh berries and orange, is a surefire hit for anyone needing a morning lift. Their flatbreads and wraps carry that same signature freshness, built for a quick lunch or easy breakfast. The Island Green smoothie, packed with spinach and mango, stands out for both the flavor and the boost of energy it offers.
3. Starbucks
Starbucks in Selden offers the classic comfort that many coffee lovers rely on when routine calls. It’s where I often find myself before long workdays, jotting notes at a corner table while the familiar sound of steamers hums in the background. This location manages to make you feel both at home and in touch with what’s happening outside.
Their Pike Place Roast remains a staple for good reason, offering a smooth, balanced cup every time. If you need something cooler, the Iced Brown Sugar Oatmilk Shaken Espresso is a must—rich, slightly sweet, and satisfying without the sugar rush. Pair either brew with their spinach, feta, and egg white wrap for a reliable and quick breakfast option.
4. Zara’s Deli and Bagel
Zara’s Deli and Bagel is where early risers and late-breakfast seekers cross paths for a strong cup and a fresh bagel. The place buzzes with energy in the mornings. I stopped in once while rushing between errands, and the way the staff handled the busy counter—calm, quick, never missing a smile—told me this spot has its priorities in order.
Their coffee gets straight to the point: hot, robust, and reliable. But the real reason to linger is the bagels, pillowy and crisp, perfect with a smear of cream cheese. Pair a classic cup with a vegetable omelette on a bagel, and you’ll see why Zara’s attracts a steady local crowd. It’s casual, friendly, and always fresh.
5. Starbucks Coffee
Starbucks Coffee in Selden delivers that familiar experience, but with a local warmth that regulars appreciate. On days when I need a reset, I’ll head here, knowing there’s a cozy spot and a dependable buzz of conversation that always feels welcoming.
The coffee is what you expect—crafted to be consistent, smooth, and tailored to your taste. Their Flat White, with its velvety texture, is a top pick for those who appreciate a creamy, balanced drink. Grab a spinach and feta egg white wrap or their classic oatmeal to start your morning right. This location proves that even a well-known chain can embrace the quirks and charm of Selden’s coffee community.
6. Peet’s Coffee & Tea
(631) 732-9114Call
Peet’s Coffee & Tea adds a West Coast flair to Selden’s caffeine scene, all bold aromas and deep, inviting brews. This shop caught my attention on a search for something with a little extra punch, and it did not disappoint. The staff knows their beans, and every cup reflects that care.
The Major Dickason’s Blend stands out, famous for its rich, full-bodied taste and smooth finish. It’s perfect if you like your coffee with plenty of character but none of the bitterness. Pair it with one of their fresh pastries or a simple bagel for a relaxed and satisfying breakfast. Peet’s brings a cozy feel that keeps you coming back—and lingers in your mind long after you leave.
7. All Around Coffee Cup
(631) 846-1966Call
All Around Coffee Cup is one of those spots you wander into once and end up calling your go-to. The charm here lies in how low-key the shop feels while still delivering coffee that’s fresh and carefully brewed. My first time inside, I ended up chatting about roast profiles with the barista while rain tapped on the windows.
The drip coffee is a local favorite—rich, aromatic, and straightforward. It’s the kind of cup that rewards you with each sip and pairs well with their toasted bagels or a buttery croissant. All Around Coffee Cup quietly earns its reputation on honest service and a focus on the small, everyday rituals that make great coffee memorable.
8. Caffe Amici
Caffe Amici blends the energy of a neighborhood cafe with the welcoming spirit of an Italian trattoria. Each visit feels like stepping into a family kitchen, filled with the scent of fresh espresso and home-baked pastries. I once found myself lingering long after a coffee, chatting with the staff about their favorite menu highlights.
Their cappuccino is a standout, frothy and perfectly balanced, best enjoyed alongside a flaky almond croissant. If you want to linger, try their egg dishes or a classic Italian breakfast sandwich. The atmosphere here is warm, and the attention to detail shows in every plate and cup. Caffe Amici easily earns its crowd of loyal fans—and new arrivals who quickly become regulars.
9. IpA Of Nassau-Suffolk Counties Inc
(631) 698-1900Call
IpA Of Nassau-Suffolk Counties Inc holds a certain old-school charm that makes it a unique stop along Middle Country Road. The no-nonsense attitude here means you get your coffee quick, hot, and exactly how you want it. I dropped in once with a tight schedule and left almost too efficiently caffeinated.
The drip brew is strong and simple, perfect for those who value tradition over trends. Pair it with one of their classic breakfast plates or a toasted bagel for a satisfying start to the day. IpA’s laid-back, cafeteria-style approach appeals to those who want honest service and reliable, straightforward choices without pretension.
10. Proportion Cafe
(631) 732-3377Call
Proportion Cafe is low-key, but it’s one of those places that wins you over with the little things. On my visit, I appreciated how every table seemed to have its own crowd—students hunched over laptops, locals swapping gossip, and the occasional crossword fan fueling up for the day.
Their signature lattes are worth a detour, especially the perfectly balanced house blend. For a quick bite, the fresh-baked muffins or a classic egg and cheese sandwich pair nicely with any coffee here. Proportion Cafe is all about familiar comforts, served fast and made just right, making it a quietly reliable option in Selden’s coffee lineup.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best coffee shops in Selden, NY?
Some favorites include Coffee Booths, Tropical Smoothie Cafe, Peet’s Coffee & Tea, and Caffe Amici. Each spot offers its own twist—from local roasts to Italian-inspired drinks.
Are there any coffee shops in Selden with free Wi-Fi?
Yes, most coffee shops in Selden, like Starbucks, Zara’s Deli and Bagel, and Panera Bread, offer free Wi-Fi for customers.
Where can I find vegetarian or healthy options?
Tropical Smoothie Cafe and Panera Bread both offer a variety of vegetarian and fresh menu items, perfect if you’re seeking lighter fare alongside your coffee.
Which coffee shops are good for studying or remote work?
Starbucks, Panera Bread, and Caffe Amici are known for their comfortable seating and relaxed atmosphere, plus the steady hum of background activity that suits focused work.
Do any Selden coffee shops serve breakfast or lunch?
Many do. Try Zara’s Deli and Bagel for bagel sandwiches, or Caffe Amici for Italian-inspired breakfast plates. Coffee Booths also offers hearty breakfast and lunch options.
Can I find specialty or artisan coffee in Selden?
Absolutely. Peet’s Coffee & Tea is the go-to for bold, specialty roasts. All Around Coffee Cup and Proportion Cafe serve small-batch options with a local flair.
