Nutley, NJ isn’t known for skyscrapers or sandy beaches, but it does have a knack for drawing coffee lovers from all walks of life. The search for a good cup of coffee in Nutley isn’t hard—if you know where to look. I’ve spent plenty of afternoons tracing the aroma of fresh brews through tree-lined streets, sometimes stumbling upon a quirky nook, other days pausing in a sunlit café where the coffee is just as strong as the sense of community.
The coffee scene here is surprisingly vibrant. Behind every storefront is a story, whether it’s crafted in a tiny family-owned shop or poured by a barista perfecting their third-wave expertise. This list brings together the highlights, from the dependable classics to hidden spots that might just become your new go-to. If you’re after something more than just a caffeine fix—maybe good conversation, a peaceful spot to read, or a pastry that actually lives up to its promise—you’re in the right place. Each place on this list has earned its spot with something that makes it stand out. Dive in and find your favorite cup.
Where to find the best coffee shops in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best coffee shops in Nutley, NJ:
- Chestnut Cafe & Eatery
- Starbucks
- Carvel
- Starbucks Coffee
- Salt of the Earth Restaurant& Coffee Bar
- JC Caffe Molisano
- Classic Coffee
- Lu Caffe Inc Caffe
- Cafe Caffe
- Cupily Coffee House
1. Chestnut Cafe & Eatery
Chestnut Cafe & Eatery feels like the spot you wish you’d found sooner. Sun pours through the front windows, casting a calm glow over the bright seating and bustling counter. Sit for a while and you’ll notice regulars sliding into booths, catching up over steaming mugs—proof you can relax or get work done here.
What sets Chestnut Cafe apart is its personal touch. The staff greet you with warmth, and service never feels rushed. The coffee isn’t just hot; it’s smooth and thoughtfully made. If you’re hungry, try the Avocado Toast or the classic omelet, both reliable picks for those who appreciate quality.
Pair your coffee with a fresh pastry for a little indulgence. This is the kind of place that quickly earns a spot in your weekly routine.
2. Starbucks
Sometimes consistency counts, and the Starbucks on Franklin Ave delivers every time. It’s spacious, with tables for group study, solo work sessions, or casual meet-ups. There’s a steady hum, but it’s never overwhelming—perfect for people-watching or catching up on emails.
The real charm here is knowing exactly what you’ll get. If routine matters, this spot rewards you. The staff handle morning rushes while still managing the occasional special request. For a classic pick, their Pike Place Roast deserves mention—rich, balanced, and just what you need to start the day.
If you’re feeling adventurous, indulge in a caramel macchiato. Pair it with a butter croissant for a touch of comfort. Starbucks blends reliability with a hint of local flavor in Nutley.
3. Carvel
Carvel on Franklin Ave isn’t just about childhood nostalgia—it’s a spot that manages to charm adults, too. While most know it for ice cream, the freshly brewed coffee here is a quiet surprise. It pairs better than expected with a scoop of their smooth vanilla soft serve if you want something different.
The atmosphere is light and friendly. You’ll find a steady flow of families and students stopping in for a sweet break. Service is quick, so you’re never waiting long for a treat or a cup of coffee.
A personal favorite is grabbing their classic soft serve in a cup, with a hot coffee on the side. For anyone with a sweet tooth looking for a cozy sugar-and-caffeine fix, Carvel hits the mark without pretense.
4. Starbucks Coffee
Starbucks Coffee on Franklin Ave feels like the anchor of Nutley’s coffee scene. Whether you’re an early riser or a late-night studier, their doors promise a familiar break from the everyday rush. The atmosphere is open, with a calm buzz that makes getting things done easy.
What I appreciate here is the attention to detail. Orders are correct, and staff remember faces and favorite drinks. If you want to keep it simple, go for the brewed coffee or a soothing green tea. Both deliver steady comfort in a cup.
If you’re after something richer, the espresso beverages shine. Paired with a plain bagel or their protein box, it’s a straightforward win when you need quality on the go.
5. Salt of the Earth Restaurant& Coffee Bar
Salt of the Earth Restaurant & Coffee Bar is a hidden gem where comfort and quality come together. The rustic décor sets a relaxing tone, and you often spot neighbors enjoying long conversations over drinks. This spot stands out for its blend of hearty meals and serious coffee. The place feels welcoming, whether you’re meeting a friend or just need a quiet table to recharge.
On my last visit, I started with a rich americano that was smooth and bright—a step above your typical diner fare. The food menu is full of satisfying options, but the breakfast choices and fresh-baked pastries really shine early in the day.
Pair a cappuccino with their house-made scones for an unbeatable combo. Salt of the Earth elevates the basics, making each visit feel special in its own unpretentious way.
6. JC Caffe Molisano
(973) 661-0408Call
JC Caffe Molisano has the understated vibe of a true neighborhood cafe. There’s no fuss here—just friendly staff, aromatic coffee, and regulars who genuinely seem at home. This spot stands out for its authentic European-style espresso drinks, served with a simple elegance that’s hard to find elsewhere in Nutley.
I’ve dropped in for a quick pick-me-up and ended up lingering over an espresso and a good book. The seating invites you to stay, with sunlight filtering in and chatter blending softly in the background.
Try the classic cappuccino, or if you want something cool, their iced coffee is refreshingly bold. A small pastry or biscotti seals the deal for a relaxed coffee break that feels effortlessly satisfying.
7. Classic Coffee
(973) 284-0363Call
Classic Coffee has a no-frills charm that’s easy to love. Tucked away on Robert St, it feels like the kind of place only locals know about. The appeal here is in the pure focus on good coffee and friendly service. You’re never rushed, and you can count on your cup being just right, every time.
I stopped by on a chilly morning and was greeted by the rich scent of freshly brewed coffee. There are no elaborate frills, just the satisfaction of a well-crafted drink and a quiet, welcoming space that encourages conversation or reflection.
Order the house blend for smooth, classic flavor. If you like a little sweet with your coffee, pick up a homemade muffin. Classic Coffee proves that simple, well-executed basics can still set a place apart.
8. Lu Caffe Inc Caffe
Lu Caffe Inc Caffe on Washington Ave is a little treasure for those who love Italian café culture without any fuss. The space is low-key and inviting, where locals linger over simple, well-prepared coffee. What makes Lu Caffe stand out is its true dedication to espresso and straightforward hospitality.
I once stopped in on a rainy afternoon, hoping for a quick espresso—and stayed much longer than planned. There’s something about the balanced flavor of their espresso that encourages you to slow down a little.
If you’re new, start with the classic espresso or a rich cappuccino. Pair it with a biscotti for a little sweet crunch. Lu Caffe is proof that sometimes, the basics done well are all you need.
9. Cafe Caffe
(973) 466-1440Call
Cafe Caffe on Chestnut St has a laid-back feel that draws you in. It’s unpretentious, with comfortable seating and a sense that everyone is welcome. The real standout here is the consistently smooth, full-bodied coffee, perfect for winding down or powering through an afternoon.
I wandered in on a weekday and found regulars engaged in easy conversation, a subtle sign of its neighborhood appeal. The atmosphere isn’t fussy—just honest and relaxing.
Their house coffee is a safe bet, but don’t skip the lattes. They’re creamy and perfectly balanced. For a treat, add a freshly baked muffin to your order. Cafe Caffe celebrates the simple joys of coffee done right.
10. Cupily Coffee House
(973) 939-5770Call
Cupily Coffee House on Franklin Ave feels like a breath of fresh air—modern, bright, and buzzing with conversation. This café stands out for its inviting energy and diverse coffee menu, always brewed with care. It’s a spot where students, friends, and families gather for more than just caffeine.
I stopped here during a busy afternoon and found it impossible not to smile at the cheerful service. The baristas are happy to walk you through their choices, and the daily specials keep things interesting.
A must-try is their cold brew, which is strong, smooth, and never bitter. Pair it with a homemade pastry or a slice of their coffee cake for an afternoon pick-me-up that manages to feel both cozy and lively.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best coffee shops in Nutley, NJ?
Nutley is home to a wide range of coffee spots, including local favorites like Chestnut Cafe & Eatery, Classic Coffee, and Cupily Coffee House. Chains like Starbucks and Dunkin’ also have popular outposts. Each offers its unique take on drinks and treats.
Are there any Nutley coffee shops with free Wi-Fi?
Yes, most shops—including Chestnut Cafe & Eatery, Starbucks, and Cupily Coffee House—provide free Wi-Fi. These spots are great for getting work done or catching up with friends online.
Can I find any coffee shops in Nutley that open early?
Absolutely. Places like Dunkin’, Starbucks, and many local cafes open early to fuel your morning. Check each spot’s hours, as some may open even before sunrise for that first cup.
Do Nutley coffee shops serve food as well?
Most coffee shops here offer breakfast, light lunches, and pastries alongside coffee. For a more filling meal, Salt of the Earth Restaurant & Coffee Bar and Nutley Diner are solid options for food and coffee combined.
Are there options for non-coffee drinkers?
Definitely. Many shops serve a range of teas, hot chocolate, and crafted cold drinks. Ochado USA, for example, is known for its specialty teas.