Searching for the best coffee shops in Seaford, NY feels a bit like treasure hunting—except you’re guaranteed to find gold at nearly every turn. This corner of Long Island has more than its fair share of charming cafés, reliable chains, and cozy nooks where you can sip something special. I’ve spent more mornings than I care to count exploring these spots, each one with its own signature vibe and—sometimes—surprisingly good bagels.
As someone deeply invested in the perfect cup, I’ve navigated Seaford’s coffee scene from quick grab-and-go espresso shots to leisurely weekend meetups in sunlit booths. Whether you crave a frothy cappuccino, cold brew for the road, or a quiet spot to chat with friends, you’ll find a cafe here that feels like it was designed just for you. Let’s break down the standouts in a way that makes finding your next caffeine fix easy, fun, and a little adventurous.
Where to find the best coffee shops in Seaford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best coffee shops in Seaford, NY:
- Tim Horton’s
- Starbucks Coffee
- Sippy Cups Cafe
- Parkside Cafe
- Tony Louies Cafe
- East Bay Diner
- Dunkin’
- The Cup Coffee House
- Peet’s Coffee & Tea
- Town Coffee Shop
1. Tim Horton’s
Tim Horton’s at 4030 Merrick Rd quietly holds its ground as a reliable daily stop. I’ve started many Seaford mornings with their Original Blend coffee—fresh, smooth, and brewed every twenty minutes, so the taste is never stale. The hum of the shop and the friendly counter staff set a relaxed tone that keeps regulars coming back.
One reason this spot stands out is the wide spread of options. The Iced Capp never disappoints—creamy, cold, and not too sweet, it’s an easy summer favorite. If you’re hungry, their breakfast sandwiches with freshly cracked eggs are always made to order and pair well with any drink on the menu.
For a quick treat, try the classic Timbits—bite-sized donut holes perfect for sharing or solo snacking. With quality choices and a welcoming vibe, Tim Horton’s brings a taste of Canada right to Seaford.
2. Starbucks Coffee
Starbucks Coffee at 3870 Sunrise Hwy manages to deliver the predictability we all crave along with a touch of community. During morning rush hour, the line at the drive-thru moves with a quiet efficiency I’ve come to appreciate, especially on days when time is tight.
What sets this shop apart in Seaford is the consistency. Every cup—whether classic Pike Place or a bright blonde roast—tastes just as it should. The space features cozy corners and plenty of outlets, which makes it popular for work or low-key meetups.
It’s hard to go wrong with a Caffè Americano for its rich, deep flavor, or a Caramel Macchiato when something sweeter is in order. For a quick snack, their warm banana bread is a top pick with a hot cup.
3. Sippy Cups Cafe
Sippy Cups Cafe at 3890 Merrick Rd defies expectations with a quirky name and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. My first visit was motivated by curiosity, and I ended up staying far longer than planned, thanks to the inviting vibe and playful decor.
What really sets Sippy Cups apart is its focus on families without sacrificing quality coffee for adults. While kids have space to play, grown-ups enjoy a genuinely good cup in peace. It’s a rare mix that absolutely works.
The house coffee blend is smooth and comforting, and their freshly-baked muffins are a must—moist, flavorful, and still warm from the oven. For something a little different, the iced chai latte strikes a perfect balance of spice and sweetness.
4. Parkside Cafe
(516) 785-2390Call
Parkside Cafe at 2479 Adler Ct feels like that neighborhood secret known mostly by Seaford locals. I’ve ducked in on rainy afternoons and discovered a laid-back space perfect for lingering over a good book. There’s always a comforting hum of conversation, just enough to feel lively without overwhelming the senses.
What distinguishes Parkside Cafe is its laid-back vibe and a menu with reliable classics. The freshly brewed coffee is robust and always served piping hot, making it ideal for a proper morning wake-up or a quiet afternoon.
If you’re hungry, their bagel breakfast sandwiches are especially satisfying—warm, toasty, and generously filled. Grab a seat by the window, order their signature coffee, and you’ll start to see why Parkside earns devoted regulars.
5. Tony Louies Cafe
(516) 513-0323Call
Tucked away at 1047 Hicksville Rd, Tony Louies Cafe has the easygoing charm that’s tough to fake. I wandered in one quiet morning and immediately noticed the relaxed energy—there’s no rush here, just a comfortable spot to settle in with a hot drink.
The staff greet regulars by name, which says a lot about the community feel. You’ll find a menu focused on classic favorites, prepared with genuine care. It’s the kind of spot where you can get actual work done or just chat with friends without feeling crowded out.
The coffee is rich and never bitter, standing up well on its own. If you’re hungry, their breakfast wraps are a local favorite for good reason—filling, flavorful, and made fresh to order.
6. East Bay Diner
(516) 781-5300Call
East Bay Diner at 3360 Merrick Rd does a fine job blending classic diner comfort with a reliable coffee shop experience. I’ve lost count of how many times a craving for an early breakfast or a late cup has drawn me through its doors. The spacious booths and welcoming staff make it a favorite for solo visits and big groups alike.
This spot stands out because it feels like a fixture in the neighborhood. Whether you’re after a bottomless cup of strong, hot diner coffee or something heartier, East Bay delivers with consistency and speed.
Their omelets and pancakes are standouts, and both are perfect alongside a fresh brew. If you love a classic no-frills spot where the coffee keeps coming, this is it.
7. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ at 1041 Hicksville Rd is a local go-to for quick comfort and familiar favorites. No matter how hectic the morning gets, I know a smooth cup of their Original Blend coffee will always be consistent. It’s the type of spot where the line moves fast and there’s always something new to try.
Part of Dunkin’s appeal is the variety. Beyond the classics, the iced coffee comes in endless flavors, and the breakfast sandwiches are reassuringly solid. If you’re in a hurry, grab a made-to-order sandwich and a cup to-go—it won’t slow you down.
The hash browns and freshly baked bagels round out the experience. Dunkin’ does the basics well, and sometimes that’s exactly what hits the spot in Seaford.
8. The Cup Coffee House
The Cup Coffee House at 3268 Railroad Ave in Wantagh is one of those rare finds that draws you back every time you’re nearby. I remember my first visit: late afternoon, rain outside, and a rich aroma that was impossible to resist the moment I walked in.
This cozy shop stands out for its blend of friendliness and creativity. The baristas know their craft—your coffee isn’t just handed over, it’s made with care. Classic drinks shine here, but specialty options are even better.
Try their signature lattes, which are always balanced and flavorful, or the cold brew on a hot day for a smooth, cooling pick-me-up. Don’t pass on the fresh pastries—they complete the experience with a sweet note.
9. Peet’s Coffee & Tea
(516) 797-3165Call
Peet’s Coffee & Tea at 4938 Merrick Rd in Massapequa Park delivers a level of boldness that’s hard to beat. Whenever I’m nearby, I can’t resist stealing a few minutes for a cup—it’s that robust, deeply roasted aroma that always does it.
What gives Peet’s an edge over other chains is the strength and flavor of the beans. Their commitment to freshness shines in every cup, and it’s easy to taste the difference. The staff are passionate coffee nerds—in the best way possible.
The Major Dickason’s Blend is a must-try for those who love intensity, while their chai tea lattes offer a creamy, spiced twist. Pick up a morning bun to go and you’ve struck the trifecta of flavor, quality, and satisfaction.
10. Town Coffee Shop
(516) 785-9461Call
Town Coffee Shop at 195 Bedford Ave in Bellmore is a throwback in all the best ways. I popped in on a whim and ended up staying for the sense of nostalgia and the conversations drifting between the tables. There’s something about the worn-in booths and the simple menu that just works.
It stands out because it’s unpretentious. Regulars know the staff by name and the coffee is reliably strong, served in classic, no-nonsense mugs. This is the kind of spot that makes you want to stay a while, just taking in the scene.
Go for their house blend—it’s comforting, straightforward, and ideal for refills. If you’re hungry, the grilled cheese or a fresh muffin pairs well with any cup in the house.
More Things to Try in Seaford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some of the best coffee shops in Seaford, NY?
Some favorites include Tim Horton’s, Parkside Cafe, Tony Louies Cafe, and Sippy Cups Cafe. Each spot has its own style, so you’re never short on options for your ideal cup.
Do any Seaford coffee shops offer free Wi-Fi?
Yes, most coffee shops like Starbucks and local favorites such as The Cup Coffee House provide free Wi-Fi. It’s easy to settle in with your laptop or connect while you sip.
Are there any coffee shops in Seaford with a family-friendly atmosphere?
Sippy Cups Cafe is especially family-friendly, offering a space where kids are welcome and parents can enjoy their drinks.
Which coffee shops have breakfast or lunch menus?
Many spots, including East Bay Diner and Tim Horton’s, serve more than just drinks. You’ll find breakfast sandwiches, pancakes, and baked goods along with top-notch coffee.
Do any Seaford coffee shops have drive-thru service?
Both Dunkin’ and Starbucks on Sunrise Hwy have drive-thru options for quick, convenient coffee runs.
Can I find specialty drinks or seasonal flavors in Seaford coffee shops?
Absolutely. Places like Starbucks and Peet’s Coffee & Tea often feature seasonal favorites, while independent shops whip up specialty lattes and creative brews year-round.
