10 Best Select Coffees: Smooth Caramel and Cocoa Picks

What are the best select coffees?
Drawing from my experience sipping many cups of coffees like Green Mountain Coffee Roasters’ Colombia Select, I’m offering a guide that highlights top choices with smooth notes of caramel and cocoa to match your taste.

I have sipped many cups of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters’ Colombia Select, and it always fills my morning with smooth notes of caramel and cocoa. This guide draws from my deep knowledge to help you pick the best select coffees for your taste. You will find clear choices that make every brew perfect. Read on to discover why these coffees stand out.

List of Top 10 Select Coffees

Image Title Best For Price
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 Count Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 Count

This coffee is perfect for busy people who love high-quality coffee but want a quick brew every morning. It’s also great for anyone who cares about the environment and likes sustainable choices that support farmers.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup pods, Medium Roast, 32 Count Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup pods, Medium Roast, 32 Count

This medium roast coffee is perfect for coffee lovers who want a bold flavor of caramel and cocoa with a smooth finish. It’s also great for those who care about sustainability, as we use fair trade methods to help farmers.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Keurig Single Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 60 Count, (6 Packs of 10) Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Keurig Single Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 60 Count, (6 Packs of 10)

This Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select medium roast coffee in K-Cup pods is perfect for folks who crave a smooth, rich cup packed with caramel and cocoa notes from Colombia. It’s ideal for those who use Keurig machines and care about sustainable, fair trade choices.

PEScience Select Cafe Protein Coffee Flavored Powder, Caramel Macchiato, 100mg Caffeine, 20g Iced Protein Coffee Powder or Creamer, 20 Servings PEScience Select Cafe Protein Coffee Flavored Powder, Caramel Macchiato, 100mg Caffeine, 20g Iced Protein Coffee Powder or Creamer, 20 Servings

This protein coffee powder is perfect for busy people who want a quick, tasty way to fuel up with 20 grams of protein and a caffeine boost, without the bitterness of regular coffee proteins. It’s ideal for anyone mixing it into iced shakes, hot drinks, or even using it as a creamer in morning coffee for creamy, satisfying energy on the go.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, Colombia Select, Ground Coffee, Fair Trade Select, Medium Roast, Bagged 10oz Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, Colombia Select, Ground Coffee, Fair Trade Select, Medium Roast, Bagged 10oz

This coffee is perfect for busy coffee lovers who want a smooth, rich taste every morning. It suits folks who care about fair trade and quality beans without any fuss.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count

This coffee is perfect for busy people who love a smooth, rich cup of medium roast every morning. It’s great for families or office workers who need easy, single-serve pods for their Keurig brewers.

HEB Cafe Ole Texas Pecan Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2 lb HEB Cafe Ole Texas Pecan Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2 lb

This Texas Pecan coffee is perfect for coffee fans who love a rich, nutty taste in their morning cup. It’s ideal for anyone seeking a bold, flavorful drink that brings the Lone Star State to life.

Victor Allen's Coffee 100% Colombian, Medium Roast, 42 Count, Single Serve Coffee Pods for Keurig K-Cup Brewers Victor Allen’s Coffee 100% Colombian, Medium Roast, 42 Count, Single Serve Coffee Pods for Keurig K-Cup Brewers

This coffee is perfect for coffee fans who love a smooth, medium roast with a rich and bright flavor from 100% Colombian beans. It’s ideal for busy people who use Keurig machines and want an easy and convenient way to enjoy high-quality coffee at home.

Keurig Coffee Pods K-Cups 16 / 18 / 22 / 24 Count Capsules ALL BRANDS / FLAVORS (24 Pods Green Mountain - Colombia Select) Keurig Coffee Pods K-Cups 16 / 18 / 22 / 24 Count Capsules ALL BRANDS / FLAVORS (24 Pods Green Mountain – Colombia Select)

Coffee fans who brew with Keurig machines will love this pack. It’s just right for anyone who wants easy single-serve coffee each day.

Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count (Pack of 2) Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count (Pack of 2)

Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select is perfect for coffee lovers who crave a bright and balanced medium roast every morning. It’s ideal for those who want a caffeinated boost that’s fair trade certified and kosher.

Detailed Reviews

This guide picks the top 10 Select Coffees by mixing expert checks and user votes. We review each one for its key traits, how it works, and true worth. No matter if you want ease or low cost, we show the best fit for you. Dive in to find your ideal pick.

1. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 Count

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 Count

This medium roast coffee from Green Mountain Coffee Roasters comes from the rich mountains of Colombia. It tastes like ripened fruits, with notes of caramel and cocoa for a-smooth, easy drink. Farmers get a fair price to help their communities.

Enjoy it in your Keurig machine with these easy K-Cup pods. They are recyclable, so you can peel, empty, and recycle them.

Pros Cons
  • Smooth, rich flavor with caramel and cocoa notes.
  • Fair Trade certified for farmer support and sustainability.
  • Compatible with all Keurig K-Cup coffee makers.
  • Medium roast using 100% Arabica beans.
  • Recyclable pods for easy eco-friendly disposal.
  • Plastic pods create waste despite recyclability.
  • Per-cup cost is higher than ground coffee.
  • Limits to other coffee makers.

Perfect For:

This coffee is perfect for busy people who love high-quality coffee but want a quick brew every morning. It’s also great for anyone who cares about the environment and likes sustainable choices that support farmers.

Ready to Purchase?

2. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup pods, Medium Roast, 32 Count

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup pods, Medium Roast, 32 Count

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters brings you the taste of the mountains. This is where our bold spirit was born. We make coffee that feels alive and strong.

You will love the smooth flavor of Colombia Select. It mixes caramel and cocoa with fresh fruits.

Enjoy a medium roast made from 100% Arabica beans. These are Keurig K-Cup pods for easy use in your maker. They show our work for fair trade and the earth.

Pros Cons
  • Savor rich caramel and fruit flavors.
  • Medium roast delivers smooth taste.
  • Fair Trade aids coffee farmers.
  • Fits all Keurig brewers easily.
  • Enjoy sustainable mountain-grown coffee.
  • Costs more per single cup.
  • Single-use pods add to waste.
  • Works only with Keurig machines.

Perfect For:

This medium roast coffee is perfect for coffee lovers who want a bold flavor of caramel and cocoa with a smooth finish. It’s also great for those who care about sustainability, as we use fair trade methods to help farmers.

Ready to Purchase?

3. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Keurig Single Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 60 Count, (6 Packs of 10)

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Keurig Single Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 60 Count, (6 Packs of 10)

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters makes Colombia Select to bring you a rich coffee from the mountains. This medium roast Arabica coffee has notes of caramel, cocoa, and fruits for a smooth finish.

It’s Fair Trade Certified so farmers get a fair price for their work. The K-Cup pods fit all Keurig makers for easy brewing. You can recycle the pods after use in many places.

Pros Cons
  • Bold flavor with caramel, cocoa, and ripe fruits.
  • Sustainably sourced to support farmers and communities.
  • Perfect fit for all Keurig K-Cup coffee makers.
  • Easy to recycle after enjoying your coffee.
  • Kosher certified medium roast with pure Arabica beans.
  • High cost per single cup
  • Not always easy to recycle everywhere
  • Uses plastic pods for waste

Perfect For:

This Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select medium roast coffee in K-Cup pods is perfect for folks who crave a smooth, rich cup packed with caramel and cocoa notes from Colombia. It’s ideal for those who use Keurig machines and care about sustainable, fair trade choices.

Ready to Purchase?

4. PEScience Select Cafe Protein Coffee Flavored Powder, Caramel Macchiato, 100mg Caffeine, 20g Iced Protein Coffee Powder or Creamer, 20 Servings

PEScience Select Cafe Protein Coffee Flavored Powder, Caramel Macchiato, 100mg Caffeine, 20g Iced Protein Coffee Powder or Creamer, 20 Servings

PEScience Select Cafe is a protein coffee powder with a rich caramel macchiato flavor. It packs 20g of protein from whey and casein to keep you full. You get a smooth, creamy drink without any bitter coffee taste.
Drink it hot, iced, or blended for easy prep. Add it to your coffee for more protein and 100mg of caffeine boost.
We’ve had third-party testing since 2010 to ensure top quality. This powder works as both a creamer and a shake base. Grab yours today and start your energized morning.

Pros Cons
  • 20g of protein fuels your day without bitterness.
  • Gets you energized with 100mg caffeine per scoop.
  • Mixes easily into iced, hot, or blended drinks.
  • Acts as a delicious creamer for your morning coffee.
  • Third-party tested for top quality you can trust.
  • Contains caffeine, may cause jitters.
  • Dairy-based, not good for vegans.
  • May clump if not mixed well.

Perfect For:

This protein coffee powder is perfect for busy people who want a quick, tasty way to fuel up with 20 grams of protein and a caffeine boost, without the bitterness of regular coffee proteins. It’s ideal for anyone mixing it into iced shakes, hot drinks, or even using it as a creamer in morning coffee for creamy, satisfying energy on the go.

Ready to Purchase?

5. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, Colombia Select, Ground Coffee, Fair Trade Select, Medium Roast, Bagged 10oz

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, Colombia Select, Ground Coffee, Fair Trade Select, Medium Roast, Bagged 10oz

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters brings you a smooth medium roast from Colombia. This ground coffee mixes plums and apricots with cocoa and caramel for a rich finish. It is 100% Arabica and ready to brew in a 10oz bag.

Choose this Fair Trade Certified coffee for great taste. It is also Kosher and full of caffeine to start your day.

Pros Cons
  • Tasty mix of plums and cocoa makes smooth coffee.
  • Medium roast gives a rich, balanced flavor.
  • Fair Trade ensures ethical and quality sourcing.
  • 100% Arabica beans create pure, superior taste.
  • Kosher certified for trusted, clean enjoyment.
  • Small bag size may require frequent reordering.
  • Only medium roast may not suit all tastes.
  • Ground coffee freshness degrades faster than whole bean.

Perfect For:

This coffee is perfect for busy coffee lovers who want a smooth, rich taste every morning. It suits folks who care about fair trade and quality beans without any fuss.

Ready to Purchase?

6. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count

Wake up to the rich taste of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select. This medium roast coffee comes in 24 single-serve Keurig K-Cup pods, perfect for your daily brew.

Enjoy notes of caramel and cocoa that blend with the bright warmth of plums and apricots. Each cup delivers a smooth, rich finish. Brew it in your Keurig brewer for an easy morning ritual.

Discover a classically balanced flavor that’s vibrant and complex. It has a splash of ripe fruit to excite your senses. Grab your pack today and start your day right.

Pros Cons
  • Smooth, rich taste with caramel and cocoa notes.
  • Balanced medium roast for vibrant flavor daily.
  • Easy single-serve pods for quick coffee brewing.
  • Ethically sourced from fair trade Colombian beans.
  • 24 convenient packs save time and effort.
  • Only compatible with Keurig brewers.
  • Medium roast may seem too mild.
  • Fair Trade pricing could be higher.

Perfect For:

This coffee is perfect for busy people who love a smooth, rich cup of medium roast every morning. It’s great for families or office workers who need easy, single-serve pods for their Keurig brewers.

Ready to Purchase?

7. HEB Cafe Ole Texas Pecan Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2 lb

HEB Cafe Ole Texas Pecan Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2 lb

Dive into the bold flavors of Texas Pecan Coffee. Its medium roast beans deliver a nutty twist that shines.

This 2 lb bag is perfect for coffee fans who love quality. Grind it fresh for the best taste every time. Enjoy it black or with milk.

It comes from trusted HEB Cafe Ole for real Texas flavor. Stock up today and savor the pecans. Your mornings will thank you.

Pros Cons
  • Bold Texas flavor makes coffee tasty.
  • Smooth medium roast feels just right.
  • Whole beans let you grind fresh.
  • Plenty of 2 pounds lasts a long time.
  • Pecan taste may not please everyone.
  • Requires a coffee grinder to brew.
  • Price point might seem high for some.

Perfect For:

This Texas Pecan coffee is perfect for coffee fans who love a rich, nutty taste in their morning cup. It’s ideal for anyone seeking a bold, flavorful drink that brings the Lone Star State to life.

Ready to Purchase?

8. Victor Allen’s Coffee 100% Colombian, Medium Roast, 42 Count, Single Serve Coffee Pods for Keurig K-Cup Brewers

Victor Allen's Coffee 100% Colombian, Medium Roast, 42 Count, Single Serve Coffee Pods for Keurig K-Cup Brewers

Enjoy Victor Allen’s Coffee, a medium roast made from 100% Colombian beans in 42 single-serve pods for Keurig brewers. It offers a smooth, robust taste that is lively and bright with mild acidity.

These pods use 100% Arabica coffee and are gluten-free, non-GMO, and Kosher. Brew at 8 ounces for the best flavor. Victor Allen has roasted quality coffee since 1979.

Pros Cons
  • Smooth and robust medium roast for great taste.
  • 100% Colombian Arabica coffee from top beans.
  • Kosher-certified and gluten-free for all diets.
  • High-quality pods work in Keurig brewers.
  • Lively flavor with just right caffeine boost.
  • Pods create extra waste
  • Caffeine level may be too high for some

Perfect For:

This coffee is perfect for coffee fans who love a smooth, medium roast with a rich and bright flavor from 100% Colombian beans. It’s ideal for busy people who use Keurig machines and want an easy and convenient way to enjoy high-quality coffee at home.

Ready to Purchase?

9. Keurig Coffee Pods K-Cups 16 / 18 / 22 / 24 Count Capsules ALL BRANDS / FLAVORS (24 Pods Green Mountain – Colombia Select)

Keurig Coffee Pods K-Cups 16 / 18 / 22 / 24 Count Capsules ALL BRANDS / FLAVORS (24 Pods Green Mountain - Colombia Select)

Brew a perfect cup with Keurig machines. These coffee pods fit easily. Enjoy Colombia Select flavor.

Each box has 24 pods. They are from Green Mountain. Use them for quick morning coffee.

Buy them today. Share the rich taste.

Pros Cons
  • Brew fresh coffee instantly every morning.
  • Enjoy rich flavors from Colombia Select.
  • Convenient pods for quick brewing.
  • Get a bulk pack of 24 pods.
  • Save time with easy single-serve cups.
  • Plastic pods create more waste that isn’t easily recyclable.
  • Higher cost compared to brewing with ground coffee at home.
  • Depends on having a Keurig machine to use them.

Perfect For:

Coffee fans who brew with Keurig machines will love this pack. It’s just right for anyone who wants easy single-serve coffee each day.

Ready to Purchase?

10. Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count (Pack of 2)

Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 24 Count (Pack of 2)

Start your day with the rich taste of Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select. This medium roast blend is bright and balanced for a coffee lover’s perfect cup.

It comes in single-serve Keurig K-Cup pods. The pack has 24 pods. You get two of them.

Enjoy this caffeinated drink that is fair trade certified. It is also kosher for extra peace of mind.

Pros Cons
  • Bright flavor wakes you up.
  • Balanced taste pleases every sip.
  • Fair Trade supports good farmers.
  • Kosher for pure enjoyment.
  • Easy pods make brewing fun.
  • Pricey per cup.
  • Caffeinated, not ideal for caffeine avoiders.
  • Pods create waste.

Perfect For:

Green Mountain Coffee Colombia Select is perfect for coffee lovers who crave a bright and balanced medium roast every morning. It’s ideal for those who want a caffeinated boost that’s fair trade certified and kosher.

Ready to Purchase?

Buying Guide

I have sipped many cups of select coffees, and they always brighten my mornings with rich, smooth tastes. This guide shares my personal tips to help you find the best picks that suit your style. You will get clear ideas that make each brew feel special.

  • Roast Level: Pick a medium roast for a balanced flavor that avoids bitterness. It brings out notes of caramel, cocoa, and fruit without being too strong. Medium roasts work well for daily drinking.
  • Flavor Profile: Look for flavors like caramel, cocoa, and fresh fruits for a smooth, rich drink. These notes mix well to create a vibrant cup every time. Avoid bland coffees by checking product descriptions.
  • Bean Origin: Choose coffees from Colombia for fair trade prices that help farmers. Colombian beans often give a bright, classic taste with mild acidity. This supports good farming practices.
  • Bean Quality: Go for 100% Arabica beans for top taste and smoothness. Arabica offers better flavor than other types. It ensures a high-quality brew.
  • Packaging: Select single-serve K-Cup pods for quick, mess-free brewing in Keurig machines. Pods fit easily and recycle easily after use. Ground or whole bean bags work for manual brewing.
  • Certifications: Check for Fair Trade and Kosher labels to ensure ethical sourcing. These show commitment to fair pay and quality standards. They add trust to your choice.
  • Caffeine Boost: Aim for coffees with good caffeine to start your day right. Some blends offer an energizing kick without too much bitterness. It keeps you alert and focused.
  • Protein Addition: Consider powders with protein for a fuller, sustained feeling. They blend into coffee for extra nutrition. This works great for those seeking more than just caffeine.
  • Ease of Use: Pick ready-to-brew options for simple mornings. Convenient pods or mixes save time. They let you enjoy great coffee quickly.
  • Nutritional Options: Look for blends with peanut or other nut notes for variety. Texas pecans add a nutty twist to the taste. It changes up your usual brew.
  • Brand Reputation: Choose known brands like Green Mountain Coffee Roasters for reliable quality. Their long history means trusted products. It ensures you get what you expect.